Appeals Court Strikes Down Large Wepco Verdict

Date: November 1, 2001

Source: News Room

The Wisconsin Court of Appeals has thrown out a landmark $100 million punitive damages award that Wisconsin Electric Power Co. had been ordered to pay for dumping wood chips loaded with cyanide in West Allis. A new trial has been ordered to determine a new amount in the case that had the potential to redefine the limits of punitive damages in Wisconsin. The 1st District Court of Appeals panel in Milwaukee made the decision because the damages award failed to meet Wisconsin's five-sixths law, which requires that five of six jurors in a civil trial agree on all questions essential to a verdict. In this case, the Court of Appeals determined that only 11 of 14 jurors--not the necessary 12--had voted for the $100 million award. The $4.5 million compensatory award remains intact. A Milwaukee County Circuit Court jury in July 1999 had decided that Wisconsin Electric for years had knowingly dumped wood chips laced with cyanide at lots in West Allis that were owned by the City of West Allis and Giddings & Lewis Corp. in Fond du Lac. The jury ordered the utility to pay the city and the company a total of $4.5 million in compensatory damages and $100 million in punitive damages.

Sign up to receive our free Weekly News Bulletin